Beth Orton played the very first show at Pete's Candy Store1. It opened in 19991, in a storefront at 709 Lorimer Street that has been in operation since the 1920s1, and it was Pete Caruso who named the spot Pete's Candy Store1.
By the time of our old listing it drew crowds with nightly events: a trivia night, a backyard barbecue, a spelling bee. Twenty-seven years after it opened, it still has shows on the calendar1, 2.
Researched October 2026.