New York on Tap 2008
Archive · modern edition Every bar New York on Tap knew, as it stood around 2008, with a 2026 check on each one. This page in the 2008 edition
Milk and Honey, photographed for New York on Tap
Photo from the 2008 site

A New York on Tap pick

Milk and Honey

134 Eldridge St.
Chinatown, Manhattan

In 2026

Closed; now Attaboy

Last licensed here under this name: 2014–15.

Checked October 15, 2026.

Show on the map Directions See the 2008 page

Overview

Exquisitely crafted cocktails which lost much of their luster as the prices climbed from $8 to $11 and have no settled at $15. You'll need reservations to get in the door

History

The room stayed; the name moved to Flatiron

Milk and Honey was Sasha Petraske's bar on Eldridge Street1. Our old listing warned that you'd need a reservation to get in the door, and watched the cocktails climb from eight dollars to eleven to fifteen, losing much of their luster on the way.

By late March 2013 Milk and Honey had moved to its new location in the Flatiron District2. The old room didn't stay empty: Sam Ross and Michael McIlroy opened Attaboy in it2.

In June 2024 Grub Street still had Attaboy at 134 Eldridge Street, where it had been for the past 12 years1. That's a long time to be the new bar in an old room.

Sources

  1. grubstreet.com
  2. ny.eater.com

Researched October 2026.

What's nearby