Archive · modern edition Every bar New York on Tap knew, as it stood around 2008, with a 2026 check on each one. This page in the 2008 edition
Fette Sau, photographed for New York on Tap
Photo from the 2008 site

A New York on Tap pick

Fette Sau

Bourbon and BBQ

354 Metropolitan Ave. · btwn Roebling & Havemeyer
Williamsburg North Side, Brooklyn

In 2026

Closed

Last licensed here under this name: 2025–26.

Checked October 15, 2026.

Overview

The owners of Sputen Duyvil across the street have transformed an auto-body garage into New York's most unique BBQ spot. A far ranging selection of bourbons, several microbrews on tap, and a large patio space make it a popular space for drinks as well.
The owners of the serious beer drinkers bar, Spuyten Duyvil have transformed the auto-body shop across the street into a temple of all things pig. The industrial garage space is not only home to some of the best BBQ in the burrough, it also has an enormous array of bourbons and a carefully balanced selection of brews. The former are served to discerning patrons with thick chunks of ice with eye droppers of water on the side. The latter are server in sizes ranging from the 1/2 pint to the gallon.

Why you should go

  • The wood smoker and espresso sugar rub make for some of the best BBQ to be had in any burrough.
  • Big picnic tables, gallon sizes of beer, and easily shared BBQ make foran ideal place to gather to celebrate with a big group of friends.

What you should know

  • Fette Sau is German for "fat pig."
  • The sauce provided is not to everyone's taste, but it's perfectly acceptible practice to bring your own.
  • Seating is communal on picnic tables outside and in.
  • Beer is server in mason jars for the smallest size and glass gallon jugs for the largest.
  • The wood fired smoker fills the air with the smell of char, but those with easily irritated eyes may be better off sitting outside.

History

Barbecue in a garage, beer by the gallon

Joe Carroll opened Fette Sau, German for fat pig, in 2007 in an old garage set back from Metropolitan Avenue1, 2. It had one of the most impressive bourbon collections in the city, and its mostly local beers came by the half pint, the pint or the whole gallon2. Carroll said business had slowed before the pandemic and declined sharply after it, and Fette Sau served its last meals on December 21, 2025, ending what its farewell called an incredibly vibrant 19 years1, 3.

Sources

  1. brooklyn.news12.com
  2. tollbit.gothamist.com
  3. greenpointers.com

Researched October 2026.

What's nearby