Archive · modern edition Every bar New York on Tap knew, as it stood around 2008, with a 2026 check on each one. This page in the 2008 edition
Don Hill's, photographed for New York on Tap
Photo from the 2008 site

A New York on Tap pick

Don Hill's

511 Greenwich St. · at Spring St.
SoHo/Little Italy, Manhattan

In 2026

Closed

Checked October 16, 2026.

Overview

It's dingey. It's dark. The drink are weak and it smells. But it's Don Hill's, so you've got to go just to see what all the fuss is about.

History

The rock club that workshopped Hedwig

Stephen Trask and John Cameron Mitchell worked out early versions of Hedwig and the Angry Inch at Don Hill's, as part of its drag-tastic Squeezebox parties1. The booking ran from Latin death metal to the Toilet Boys2. When we listed it, we called it dingy, dark and smelly, with weak drinks, and told you to go anyway.

Don Hill, who had helped launch Poison and LA Guns at the Cat Club2, opened the place at the corner of Spring and Greenwich Streets in 19932. The corner had been a Munson's Diner, one of a chain that dotted the city in the 1940s and '50s, and then Keith McNally's high-end restaurant Canal Bar2.

In 2010 the nightlife impresarios Paul Sevigny and Nur Khan joined Hill as partners and remodeled the club; there was still live music, now with chic parties afterward2. Hill, born Donald Mulvihill, died in March 2011 at 661, 3, and a month later Sevigny and Khan were forced to close the club1.

In December 2014 a soon-to-open replacement called The Hills was set to host a tribute to Hill with Michael C. Hall and other cast members of Hedwig1, and it was due to open the next year4. Nothing came of it5. Related Companies was said to be in talks with Ponte Equities about tearing down and rebuilding the whole block of Spring Street between Renwick and Greenwich, 511 Greenwich included5, 6. As of 2018 the old space was getting a cleaning and, one Friday night, a party7.

Sources

  1. bedfordandbowery.com
  2. amny.com
  3. wnyc.org
  4. bedfordandbowery.com
  5. tribecacitizen.com
  6. tribecacitizen.com
  7. tribecacitizen.com

Researched October 2026.

What's nearby